It’s not that I claim to be a parenting expert or anything. I suppose I’ve got some basics figured out – don’t smack them upside the head even when they deserve it, keep them clean and fed, don’t let them watch R-rated movies, always have extra diapers. I also thought that encouraging them to learn the basic life skills was a good idea. And it appears that I’m in the minority on this.

Yesterday at Ironflower’s dance class, I observed another four year old come in, plop down on the dressing room floor and hold her feet up. Her mother then removed her shoes for her. I nearly fell off the bench. This mom has always seemed perfectly sane to me. I subtly checked out the other girls and moms and it was all the same. Seemingly loving and normal moms removing shoes and clothes for their able-bodied kids. After class it was the same thing – Ironflower is the only one expected to dress herself and ask if she needs help. All the other moms dress their four year olds.

And yet I’m really bothered that almost three year old Lovebug can’t/won’t put on his own shoes. He also needs help removing shirts because he has such a big head. (No, seriously, it’s that big. I’m going to be helping him in that department until he’s like 8 or so, I swear.) But even he’s been taking off his own shoes forever. And he takes off everything else and we’re working on dressing himself.

At first I was all proud of my kids and their skills. But then I realized that maybe these kids CAN do all of these things, they just don’t have to. And I started to wonder if I should be doing these things for my kids too. Am I forcing them to be too independent? Should they just expect me to take their shoes off for them?

Fortunately I then remembered that martyrdom does not become me, so this is all really moot. Independent kids make a much less stressed Jerseygirl. In fact, I’ve even got Ironflower helping Lovebug with his shoes now, so frustrated have I become trying to teach him (or will him, rather) to put on his slip-on shoes. And we’re all a little happier in the morning.

But still, is this forced independence going to make them feel unloved? Or are those other kids being taught that they’re incapable? What are your thoughts?

PS – Leslie over at My Mommy’s Place is having another one of her haiku contests. Check it out!